Instances

Updates
  • Update (2018-11-05): MIPLIB 2017 is released. The Collection dataset includes 1 Group 1 instance (lr2-22dr3-333vc4v17a-t60), 3 Group 2 instances (lr1dr02vc05v8a-t360, lr1dr04vc05v17a-t360, lr1dr12vc10v70b-t360), and 1 Jiang-Grossmann instance (maritime-jg3d9). The main conclusion is that state-of-the-art commercial mixed-integer programming solvers continue to struggle when solving Group 1 and 2 MIRPLib instances without fit-for-purpose algorithms. The four Group 1 and 2 MIRPLib instances have all been classifed as "open," meaning that no state-of-the-art solver has declared these instances solved to provable optimality. In fact, the objective function values reported are vastly inferior to those reported on the MIRPLib website.
  • Update (2018-09-28): Friske and Buriol found 4 new best known solutions to Group 1 instances: LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V11a and LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V12b for T=45 (i.e., a planning horizon of 45 periods).
  • Update (2017-09-27): Friske and Buriol found 2 new best known solutions to Group 1 instances: LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V11a and LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V12b for T=45 (i.e., a planning horizon of 45 periods).
  • Update (2017-09-05): Papageorgiou et al. found new best known incumbents for 26 out of 70 yet-to-be-proved optimal Group 2 instances and new best known bounds on 56 of these same Group 2 instances.;

 

The Instances

Please view the legend below for more details.

The instances can be partitioned into three main groups. Group 1 and Group 2 were presented in Papageorgiou et al. (2014) and can be distinguished by the length of the planning horizon. The Jiang-Grossmann (JG) instances were presented in Jiang and Grossmann (2015).

Group 1: Instances with a planning horizon of 60 periods or fewer having multiple ports per region and often requiring split pickups or split deliveries. Finding a single feasible solution is a challenge. A mixed-integer linear programming formulation is available here.

Group 2: Instances with a planning horizon greater than 60 periods having one port per region and never involving split pickups or split deliveries. On the other hand, instances in this group possessing many ports often involve travel times ranging from 5 to 37 periods. Finding a good feasible solution in minutes is a challenge. A mixed-integer linear programming formulation is available here.

Group 3: Jiang-Grossmann (please see Jiang and Grossmann (2015) for more details)

 

Download

Complete Set

Group Name Period Objval Bound Relative Gap (%) Absolute Gap
1 LR1_1_DR1_3_VC1_V7a 45 -13272.0 -14.410.0 8.57 1138
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V11a 45 -11243.0 -12.994.0 15.58 1751
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V12a 45 -10732.0 -12.329.0 14.89 1598
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V12b 45 -9085.0 -9.578.0 5.43 493
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V8a 45 -5106.0 -6.153.0 20.51 1047
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V9a 45 -6921.0 -8.242.0 19.09 1321
1 LR1_2_DR1_3_VC2_V6a 45 -11134.0 -12.763.0 14.63 1629
1 LR1_2_DR1_3_VC3_V8a 45 -12010.0 -13.625.0 13.45 1615
1 LR2_11_DR2_22_VC3_V6a 45 -9718.0 -10.802.0 11.16 1084
1 LR2_11_DR2_33_VC4_V11a 45 -14017.0 -16.445.0 17.32 2428
1 LR2_11_DR2_33_VC5_V12a 45 -18423.0 -20.668.0 12.18 2245
1 LR2_22_DR2_22_VC3_V10a 45 -24855.0 -27.803.0 11.86 2948
1 LR2_22_DR3_333_VC4_V14a 45 -21952.0 -27.216.0 23.98 5264
1 LR2_22_DR3_333_VC4_V17a 45 -22294.0 -27.628.0 23.92 5334
1 LR1_1_DR1_3_VC1_V7a 60 -16675.0 -17.847.0 7.03 1172
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V11a 60 -13257.0 -15.020.0 13.30 1763
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V12a 60 -11040.0 -12.832.0 16.23 1792
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V12b 60 -10053.0 -11.287.0 12.27 1234
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V8a 60 -5191.0 -6.691.0 28.90 1500
1 LR1_1_DR1_4_VC3_V9a 60 -7552.0 -9.383.0 24.25 1831
1 LR1_2_DR1_3_VC2_V6a 60 -13532.0 -15.841.0 17.06 2309
1 LR1_2_DR1_3_VC3_V8a 60 -14652.0 -17.379.0 18.61 2727
1 LR2_11_DR2_22_VC3_V6a 60 -12655.0 -14.198.0 12.19 1543
1 LR2_11_DR2_33_VC4_V11a 60 -15387.0 -19.565.0 27.15 4178
1 LR2_11_DR2_33_VC5_V12a 60 -22948.0 -25.988.0 13.25 3040
1 LR2_22_DR2_22_VC3_V10a 60 -32627.0 -35.873.0 9.95 3246
1 LR2_22_DR3_333_VC4_V14a 60 -26873.0 -33.503.0 24.67 6630
1 LR2_22_DR3_333_VC4_V17a 60 -27000.0 -33.909.0 25.59 6909
2 LR1_DR02_VC01_V6a 120 33809.0 33.809.0 0.00 0
2 LR1_DR02_VC02_V6a 120 74982.0 74.982.0 0.00 0
2 LR1_DR02_VC03_V7a 120 40446.0 39.318.0 2.79 1128
2 LR1_DR02_VC03_V8a 120 43721.0 43.717.0 0.01 4
2 LR1_DR02_VC04_V8a 120 41657.0 41.277.0 0.91 380
2 LR1_DR02_VC05_V8a 120 36659.0 36.088.0 1.56 571
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V10b 120 92941.0 83.645.0 10.00 9296
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V13b 120 124921.0 118.706.0 4.98 6215
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V16a 120 82837.0 71.635.0 13.52 11202
2 LR1_DR04_VC03_V15a 120 73312.0 72.108.0 1.64 1204
2 LR1_DR04_VC03_V15b 120 117812.0 102.148.0 13.30 15664
2 LR1_DR04_VC05_V17a 120 72876.0 71.572.0 1.79 1304
2 LR1_DR04_VC05_V17b 120 105766.0 84.970.0 19.66 20796
2 LR1_DR05_VC05_V25a 120 105328.0 102.755.0 2.44 2573
2 LR1_DR05_VC05_V25b 120 137107.0 125.966.0 8.13 11141
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V38a 120 166615.0 158.499.0 4.87 8116
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V40a 120 178593.0 171.418.0 4.02 7175
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V40b 120 200746.0 188.843.0 5.93 11903
2 LR1_DR08_VC10_V40a 120 185538.0 180.353.0 2.79 5185
2 LR1_DR08_VC10_V40b 120 206315.0 195.690.0 5.15 10626
2 LR1_DR12_VC05_V70a 120 278647.0 267.766.0 3.90 10881
2 LR1_DR12_VC05_V70b 120 308555.0 294.441.0 4.57 14114
2 LR1_DR12_VC10_V70a 120 283154.0 274.121.0 3.19 9033
2 LR1_DR12_VC10_V70b 120 295126.0 285.440.0 3.28 9686
2 LR1_DR02_VC01_V6a 180 52167.0 52.166.0 0.00 1
2 LR1_DR02_VC02_V6a 180 129372.0 128.106.0 0.98 1267
2 LR1_DR02_VC03_V7a 180 60547.0 58.790.0 2.90 1757
2 LR1_DR02_VC03_V8a 180 68153.0 66.989.0 1.71 1164
2 LR1_DR02_VC04_V8a 180 66017.0 65.274.0 1.12 743
2 LR1_DR02_VC05_V8a 180 58619.0 57.260.0 2.32 1359
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V10b 180 125638.0 106.712.0 15.06 18926
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V13b 180 165764.0 143.695.0 13.31 22069
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V16a 180 143178.0 120.556.0 15.80 22622
2 LR1_DR04_VC03_V15a 180 118621.0 116.211.0 2.03 2410
2 LR1_DR04_VC03_V15b 180 189989.0 170.432.0 10.29 19557
2 LR1_DR04_VC05_V17a 180 117710.0 115.530.0 1.85 2180
2 LR1_DR04_VC05_V17b 180 159168.0 130.290.0 18.14 28879
2 LR1_DR05_VC05_V25a 180 171620.0 167.766.0 2.25 3854
2 LR1_DR05_VC05_V25b 180 205368.0 186.749.0 9.07 18619
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V38a 180 274244.0 261.036.0 4.82 13208
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V40a 180 296760.0 284.481.0 4.14 12280
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V40b 180 337559.0 294.265.0 12.83 43294
2 LR1_DR08_VC10_V40a 180 304261.0 297.805.0 2.12 6457
2 LR1_DR08_VC10_V40b 180 331775.0 304.668.0 8.17 27107
2 LR1_DR12_VC05_V70a 180 460566.0 444.823.0 3.42 15743
2 LR1_DR12_VC05_V70b 180 491160.0 461.302.0 6.08 29858
2 LR1_DR12_VC10_V70a 180 466975.0 454.280.0 2.72 12695
2 LR1_DR12_VC10_V70b 180 470172.0 454.552.0 3.32 15620
2 LR1_DR02_VC01_V6a 360 108141.0 107.994.0 0.14 147
2 LR1_DR02_VC02_V6a 360 283031.0 275.347.0 2.71 7684
2 LR1_DR02_VC03_V7a 360 124282.0 120.346.0 3.17 3936
2 LR1_DR02_VC03_V8a 360 141166.0 139.821.0 0.95 1345
2 LR1_DR02_VC04_V8a 360 138693.0 137.449.0 0.90 1244
2 LR1_DR02_VC05_V8a 360 122598.0 120.986.0 1.31 1612
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V10b 360 259888.0 212.621.0 18.19 47267
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V13b 360 316441.0 262.458.0 17.06 53983
2 LR1_DR03_VC03_V16a 360 327793.0 274.753.0 16.18 53040
2 LR1_DR04_VC03_V15a 360 252710.0 248.598.0 1.63 4112
2 LR1_DR04_VC03_V15b 360 339308.0 294.483.0 13.21 44825
2 LR1_DR04_VC05_V17a 360 251623.0 247.816.0 1.51 3807
2 LR1_DR04_VC05_V17b 360 304507.0 251.864.0 17.29 52643
2 LR1_DR05_VC05_V25a 360 368628.0 362.894.0 1.56 5734
2 LR1_DR05_VC05_V25b 360 410053.0 377.388.0 7.97 32665
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V38a 360 596969.0 575.369.0 3.62 21600
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V40a 360 652380.0 624.179.0 4.32 28201
2 LR1_DR08_VC05_V40b 360 709713.0 630.407.0 11.17 79306
2 LR1_DR08_VC10_V40a 360 663245.0 649.885.0 2.01 13360
2 LR1_DR08_VC10_V40b 360 724513.0 651.195.0 10.12 73318
2 LR1_DR12_VC05_V70a 360 1021389.0 982.619.0 3.80 38770
2 LR1_DR12_VC05_V70b 360 1093013.0 980.410.0 10.30 112603
2 LR1_DR12_VC10_V70a 360 1024399.0 1.002.624.0 2.13 21775
2 LR1_DR12_VC10_V70b 360 1001541.0 985.670.0 1.58 15871
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_0 60 6812.0 6.132.0 9.98 680
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_1 60 7632.0 6.884.0 9.80 748
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_2 60 7632.0 6.892.0 9.69 740
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_3 60 7632.0 6.896.0 9.65 736
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_4 60 6812.0 6.134.0 9.95 678
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_5 60 6812.0 6.132.0 9.99 680
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_6 60 7632.0 6.888.0 9.75 744
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_7 60 7632.0 7.632.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_8 60 7632.0 6.880.0 9.85 752
3 Group1_D_P1_C1_V2_D1_9 60 7632.0 6.874.0 9.94 758
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_0 60 6374.0 6.374.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_1 60 7044.0 7.044.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_2 60 6954.0 6.954.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_3 60 6894.0 6.894.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_4 60 6694.0 6.694.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_5 60 6634.0 6.634.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_6 60 7364.0 7.364.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_7 60 7304.0 7.304.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_8 60 7214.0 7.214.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_E_P1_C1_V2_D1_9 60 7154.0 7.154.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_0 60 6374.0 6.374.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_1 60 7044.0 7.044.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_2 60 6954.0 6.954.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_3 60 6894.0 6.894.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_4 60 6694.0 6.694.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_5 60 6634.0 6.634.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_6 60 7364.0 7.364.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_7 60 7304.0 7.304.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_8 60 7214.0 7.214.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_RS_P1_C1_V2_D1_9 60 7154.0 7.154.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_0 60 6374.0 6.374.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_1 60 7044.0 7.044.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_2 60 6954.0 6.954.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_3 60 6894.0 6.894.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_4 60 6694.0 6.694.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_5 60 6634.0 6.634.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_6 60 7364.0 7.364.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_7 60 7304.0 7.304.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_8 60 7214.0 7.214.0 0.00 0
3 Group1_S_P1_C1_V2_D1_9 60 7154.0 7.154.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_0 70 14678.0 13.210.2 10.00 1468
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_1 70 14678.0 13.210.2 10.00 1468
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_2 70 15150.0 13.635.0 10.00 1515
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_3 70 15350.0 13.815.0 10.00 1535
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_4 70 13906.0 12.515.4 10.00 1391
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_5 70 13906.0 12.515.4 10.00 1391
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_6 70 13878.0 12.222.5 11.93 1656
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_7 70 15650.0 14.085.0 10.00 1565
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_8 70 15650.0 14.085.0 10.00 1565
3 Group2_D_P2_C4_V3_D1_9 70 14706.0 13.235.4 10.00 1471
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_0 70 13200.8 13.200.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_1 70 13142.0 13.142.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_2 70 13505.2 13.505.2 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_3 70 13298.0 13.298.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_4 70 12030.0 12.030.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_5 70 11674.0 11.674.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_6 70 12138.8 12.138.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_7 70 13380.8 13.380.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_8 70 13375.2 13.375.2 0.00 0
3 Group2_E_P2_C4_V3_D1_9 70 12430.4 12.430.4 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_0 70 13200.8 13.200.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_1 70 13142.0 13.142.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_2 70 13505.2 13.505.2 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_3 70 13298.0 13.298.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_4 70 12030.0 12.030.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_5 70 11674.0 11.674.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_6 70 12138.8 12.138.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_7 70 13380.8 13.380.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_8 70 13375.2 13.375.2 0.00 0
3 Group2_RS_P2_C4_V3_D1_9 70 12430.4 12.430.4 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_0 70 13200.8 13.200.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_1 70 13142.0 13.142.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_2 70 13505.2 13.505.2 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_3 70 13298.0 13.298.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_4 70 12030.0 12.030.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_5 70 11674.0 11.674.0 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_6 70 12138.8 12.138.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_7 70 13380.8 13.380.8 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_8 70 13375.2 13.375.2 0.00 0
3 Group2_S_P2_C4_V3_D1_9 70 12430.4 12.430.4 0.00 0
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_0 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_1 70 11090.0 8.801.5 20.64 2289
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_2 70 11910.0 10.719.0 10.00 1191
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_3 70 11910.0 10.719.0 10.00 1191
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_4 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_5 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_6 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_7 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_8 70 11270.0 10.143.0 10.00 1127
3 Group3_D_P4_C3_V3_D1_9 70 Infeasible - - -
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_0 70 8109.0 8.109.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_1 70 8905.0 8.905.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_2 70 9701.0 9.701.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_3 70 9225.0 9.225.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_4 70 7941.0 7.941.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_5 70 7829.0 7.829.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_6 70 8905.0 8.905.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_7 70 8649.8 8.649.8 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_8 70 9445.0 9.445.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_E_P4_C3_V3_D1_9 70 10725.4 10.725.4 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_0 70 8109.0 8.109.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_1 70 8905.0 8.905.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_2 70 9701.0 9.701.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_3 70 9225.0 9.225.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_4 70 7941.0 7.941.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_5 70 7829.0 7.829.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_6 70 8905.0 8.905.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_7 70 8619.4 8.619.4 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_8 70 9411.4 9.411.4 0.00 0
3 Group3_RS_P4_C3_V3_D1_9 70 10691.8 10.691.8 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_0 70 8109.0 8.109.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_1 70 8905.0 8.905.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_2 70 9701.0 9.701.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_3 70 9225.0 9.225.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_4 70 7941.0 7.941.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_5 70 7829.0 7.829.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_6 70 8905.0 8.905.0 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_7 70 8619.4 8.619.4 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_8 70 9411.4 9.411.4 0.00 0
3 Group3_S_P4_C3_V3_D1_9 70 10691.8 10.691.8 0.00 0
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_0 70 14678.0 11.875.6 19.09 2802
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_1 70 14678.0 12.699.2 13.48 1979
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_2 70 15150.0 13.480.0 11.02 1670
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_3 70 14850.0 13.292.7 10.49 1557
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_4 70 13906.0 12.105.0 12.95 1801
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_5 70 13434.0 11.673.2 13.11 1761
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_6 70 14206.0 12.121.3 14.68 2085
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_7 70 14678.0 13.210.2 10.00 1468
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_8 70 14706.0 13.236.1 10.00 1470
3 Group5_D_P2_C4_V3_D2_9 70 15178.0 13.665.0 9.97 1513
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_0 70 12649.2 12.649.2 0.00 0
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_1 70 13050.8 13.050.8 0.00 0
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_2 70 13535.2 13.535.2 0.00 0
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_3 70 13235.2 11.260.2 14.92 1975
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_4 70 12027.2 10.310.5 14.27 1717
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_5 70 11555.2 10.432.5 9.72 1123
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_6 70 11555.2 11.555.2 0.00 0
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_7 70 13293.6 12.902.8 2.94 391
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_8 70 12323.2 12.323.2 0.00 0
3 Group5_E_P2_C4_V3_D2_9 70 13195.2 13.195.2 0.00 0
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_0 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_1 70 11090.0 9.981.0 10.00 1109
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_2 70 11910.0 10.719.0 10.00 1191
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_3 70 11910.0 10.719.0 10.00 1191
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_4 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_5 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_6 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_7 70 10710.0 9.639.0 10.00 1071
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_8 70 11270.0 10.143.0 10.00 1127
3 Group6_D_P4_C2_V3_D2_9 70 11910.0 10.719.0 10.00 1191
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_0 70 8109.0 8.109.0 0.00 0
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_1 70 8905.0 8.291.4 6.89 614
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_2 70 9701.0 9.328.2 3.84 373
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_3 70 9225.0 9.225.0 0.00 0
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_4 70 7941.0 7.941.0 0.00 0
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_5 70 7829.0 7.829.0 0.00 0
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_6 70 8905.0 8.672.0 2.62 233
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_7 70 8649.8 7.459.1 13.77 1191
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_8 70 9445.0 9.131.4 3.32 314
3 Group6_E_P4_C2_V3_D2_9 70 9689.4 9.689.4 0.00 0
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_0 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_1 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_2 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_3 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_4 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_5 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_6 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_7 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_8 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_D_P3_C7_V6_D1_9 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_0 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_1 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_2 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_3 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_4 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_5 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_6 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_7 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_8 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_E_P3_C7_V6_D1_9 80 Infeasible - - -
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_0 80 15214.8 15.214.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_1 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_2 80 15168.3 15.168.3 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_3 80 15700.3 15.700.3 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_4 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_5 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_6 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_7 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_8 80 15704.8 15.704.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_RS_P3_C7_V6_D1_9 80 15214.8 15.214.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_0 80 15214.8 15.214.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_1 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_2 80 15168.3 15.168.3 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_3 80 15700.3 15.700.3 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_4 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_5 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_6 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_7 80 16251.8 16.251.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_8 80 15704.8 15.704.8 0.00 0
3 Group4_S_P3_C7_V6_D1_9 80 15214.8 15.214.8 0.00 0